| Platinum | Baked & Boujee Cheesecakes |
| Gold | Harina Bakehouse |
| Silver | Saltwater & Shenanigans |
| Bronze | Red Knot Bakery |
| Top Pick | Brookfield Bakery |
| Top Pick | Gennoe's Baking |
| Top Pick | Glory Rose Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Masstown Market |
| Top Pick | Melville Corner Homestead |
| Top Pick | The Little Pastry House |