| Platinum | Frank & Gino's Grill & Pasta House |
| Gold | A-1 Pizza |
| Silver | Little Gull Bistro |
| Bronze | Boston Pizza |
| Top Pick | Andre's Seats |
| Top Pick | My Grandfather's Farm |
| Top Pick | Pictou County Pizza |
| Top Pick | Scott's Pizza |
| Top Pick | The Pizza Market |
| Top Pick | Waterview Restaurant |