| Platinum | Crossroads Country Market |
| Gold | Big Al's Convenience |
| Silver | Highland Market |
| Bronze | Big Al's New Glasgow |
| Top Pick | Earltown General Store |
| Top Pick | Mike's Drive Thru & Convenience & Tanning saloon |
| Top Pick | Muddy River Variety |
| Top Pick | Needs Convenience |
| Top Pick | Sunrise Country Market |
| Top Pick | The Amherst Candy Shoppe |