| Platinum | Johny's Java |
| Gold | Gram's Place |
| Silver | Red Knot Bakery |
| Bronze | A Slice of Home Bakery & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Amherst Shore Country Inn |
| Top Pick | Back East At Home |
| Top Pick | Jungle Jim's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | My Grandfather's Farm |
| Top Pick | Perk Me Up Cafe |
| Top Pick | The Stone Soup Cafe & Catering |