| Platinum | Curly's Canteen |
| Gold | Acropole Pizza |
| Silver | Steeltown Take Out |
| Silver | Your Place Eatery |
| Bronze | A1 Pizza |
| Bronze | Barnyard Grill Food Truck |
| Top Pick | A-1 Pizza |
| Top Pick | Back East Seafood |
| Top Pick | Mary & Larry's Diner |
| Top Pick | Waterview Restaurant |